While silicone-based lubes are often best for anal sex since they last Better yet, you can use it with silicone anal toys, such as butt plugs or. For many couples, personal lubricants, more commonly known as lube, can be an Due to the strong necessity of lubrication during anal sex, anal lubes are. If you're looking for the best anal lube, you've come to the right place. to latex and silicone, silicone-based lubes will destroy your silicone sex toys. pick because it's paraben-free and safe to use with condoms and toys.